Meeting

Form on SAB_MEETING

Public Meeting of the Chartered Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC) on Particulate Matter and Ozone

12/03/2019 to 12/06/2019



On this page:


See EPA’s PDF page to learn more about PDF files.

Meeting Agenda


Meeting Agenda

To discuss CASAC's Draft Report on EPA's Policy Assessment for Particulate Matter, to peer review EPA's Integrated Science Assessment for Ozone and Related Photochemical Oxidants (External Review Draft & September 2019), and to peer review EPA's Policy Assessment for the Review of the Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standards (External Review Draft & October 2019)

Meeting Materials


Meeting Materials


Disclaimer Although not required to do so, EPA generally posts public comments submitted to the SAB, CASAC or Council and their subcommittees on the internet to make them easily available to the public. Posting of public comments is not an Agency endorsement of, or agreement with, any information or viewpoints presented in the public comment, nor is it an Agency endorsement of the quality or correctness of such information and viewpoints. In addition, mention of any trade names or commercial products in posted meeting material does not constitute a recommendation by EPA or the SAB for use.

CategoryMeeting Material
Agency Briefing MaterialEPA Presentation - Policy Assessment for the Review of the Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standard (PDF)
Agency Briefing MaterialEPA Presentation - Review of the Integrated Science Assessment for Ozone (PDF)
Agency Follow-upShort-Term Cardiovascular Morbidity and Mortality Studies Excluded from the Draft Ozone ISA Based on Location (PDF)
Committee Members' Comments11-27-19 Preliminary CASAC Member Comments on the Ozone ISA (PDF)
Committee Members' Comments11-27-19 Preliminary CASAC Member Comments on the Ozone PA (PDF)
Committee Members' Comments12-2-19 Preliminary Ozone ISA Comments from Dr. James Boylan (PDF)
Committee Members' Comments12-4-19 Preliminary Ozone PA Comments from Dr. James Boylan (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone ISA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Corey Masuca (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone ISA Questions for Consultants from Dr. James Boylan (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone ISA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Mark Frampton (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone ISA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Sabine Lange (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone ISA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Steven Packham (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone ISA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Tony Cox (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone PA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Corey Masuca (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone PA Questions for Consultants from Dr. James Boylan (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsOzone PA Questions for Consultants from Dr. Sabine Lange (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. D. Warner North (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. Dan Jaffe (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. David Parrish (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. Duncan Thomas (updated 11-04-19) (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. Frederick Lipfert (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. Lorenz Rhomberg (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Dr. Sonja Sax (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone ISA from Mr. John J. Jansen (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Dr. D. Warner North (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Dr. Dan Jaffe (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Dr. David Parrish (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Dr. Duncan Thomas (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Dr. Frederick Lipfert (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Dr. Sonja Sax (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions on the Ozone PA from Mr. John J. Jansen (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA and Ozone PA Oral Statement from John Dale Dunn, Heartland Institute, Chicago (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from David Hill, American Lung Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from Peter Valberg and Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from Randy Mandel, Ramboll (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from Rashid Shaikh, Health Effects Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from Robert Paine, AECOM (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone ISA Oral Statement from Stewart Holm, American Forest & Paper Association and American Wood Council (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from Albert Rizzo, American Lung Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from Anne Smith, NERA Economic Consulting (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from Courtney Taylor, Ramboll (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from David Heinold, AECOM (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from John Bachmann (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from John Dale Dunn, Heartland Institute of Chicago (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOzone PA Oral Statement from Peter Valberg and Jule Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from Dan Greenbaum, Health Effects Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from Daren Bakst, The Heritage Foundation (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from John Bachmann, Environmental Protection Network (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from John Dale Dunn, Heartland Institute, Chicago (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from Rob McConnell, University of Southern California (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from Sumita Khatri, American Lung Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPM PA Oral Statement from Thomas Golab, American Council on Science and Health (revised) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff Office12-4-19 Ozone ISA Clarifying Comment from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA and Ozone PA Comments from John Dale Dunn, Heartland Institute, Chicago (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA and Ozone PA Comments from Robert Paine and David Heinold, AECOM (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA and Ozone PA Comments from the Former CASAC Ozone Panel (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA and Ozone PA Comments from the Northeast States for Coordinated Air Use Management (NESCAUM) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA Comments from Jennifer Richmond-Bryant, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA Comments from Julie Goodman and Peter Valberg, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA comments from Robert J. Paine and David W. Heinold, AECOM (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA Comments from the California Air Resources Board and the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone ISA Comments from the Health Effects Institute (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone PA Comments from Anne Smith and Garrett Glasgow, NERA Economic Consulting (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone PA Comments from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeOzone PA Comments from Julie Goodman and Peter Valberg, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from George Allen (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from Gretchen Goldman, Union of Concerned Scientists (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from James Enstrom, UCLA (retired) and Scientific Integrity Institute (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from John Bachmann, Environmental Protection Network (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from John Bachmann, Environmental Protection Network - 12-16-19 (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from John Dale Dunn, Heartland Institute, Chicago (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from Lianne Sheppard, University of Washington (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA Comments from the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePM PA, Ozone ISA, and Ozone PA Comments from the New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services (PDF)
RosterChartered CASAC Roster (PDF)

Top of Page