Meeting

Form on SAB_MEETING

Public Teleconference of the Chartered Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC) on Particulate Matter

10/22/2019
12:00 PM - 04:00 PM



On this page:


See EPA’s PDF page to learn more about PDF files.

Meeting Agenda


Meeting Agenda

The purpose of the teleconference is to receive public comments for the CASAC to consider in their peer review of the EPA's Policy Assessment for Particulate Matter on October 24-25, 2019.

Meeting Materials


Meeting Materials


Disclaimer Although not required to do so, EPA generally posts public comments submitted to the SAB, CASAC or Council and their subcommittees on the internet to make them easily available to the public. Posting of public comments is not an Agency endorsement of, or agreement with, any information or viewpoints presented in the public comment, nor is it an Agency endorsement of the quality or correctness of such information and viewpoints. In addition, mention of any trade names or commercial products in posted meeting material does not constitute a recommendation by EPA or the SAB for use.

CategoryMeeting Material
Agency-provided Background MaterialEPA Response to Dr. Frampton's Question on PM PA and Ozone ISA (PDF)
Availability of Meeting MaterialsAvailability of Meeting Materials (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsQuestions for Consultants from Dr. James Boylan (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsQuestions for Consultants from Dr. Mark Frampton (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsQuestions for Consultants from Dr. Sabine Lange (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsQuestions for Consultants from Dr. Steven Packham (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsQuestions for Consultants from Dr. Tony Cox (PDF)
Committee Members' Questions for Non-member ConsultantsSupplementary References for Causal Determination Questions from Dr. Tony Cox (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background Material10-23-19 Dr. Tony Cox's Follow-up Questions for Dr. Lianne Sheppard on Vetting the Causal Determination Framework (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background Material11-07-19 Follow-up Questions from Dr. Cox for Drs. Suh, Manjourides, Eum, and Pun (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialBiosketches of Non-member Consultants (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialSelection of Literature on Validation of Modern Causal Analysis and Inference Methods from Dr. Tony Cox (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. Constantin Aliferis (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. D. Warner North (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. Dan Jaffe (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. David Parrish (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. Duncan Thomas (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. Frederick Lipfert (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. Lorenz Rhomberg (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Dr. Sonja Sax (PDF)
Non-member Consultants' Responses to Committee Members' QuestionsResponses to CASAC Questions from Mr. John J. Jansen (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Anne Smith, NERA Economic Consulting (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Annette Rohr, Electric Power Research Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Chad Whiteman, U.S. Chamber of Commerce (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from George Allen (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Giffe Johnson, National Council for Air and Stream Improvement (NCASI) (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from John Bachmann, Envrionmental Protection Network (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Lianne Sheppard, University of Washington (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Mary Rice, American Thoracic Society Environmental Health Policy Committee (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Ned Leiba, Citizens Advisory Committee of the San Joaquin Valley California Air Pollution Control District (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Skip Brown, Asphalt Consulting Services, LLC (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Stewart Holm, American Forest & Paper Association and American Wood Council (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Ted Hadzi-Antich, Texas Public Policy Foundation (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeFollow-up Comments from Giffe Johnson, National Council for Air and Stream Improvement (NCASI) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeFollow-up Comments from Lianne Sheppard, University of Washington (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeReference Provided by Lianne Sheppard, University of Washington (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Anne Smith, NERA Economic Consulting (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from George Thurston, New York University School of Medicine, on behalf of the North American Chapter of the International Society for Environmental Epidemiology (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Giffe Johnson, National Council for Air and Stream Improvement (NCASI) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Helen Suh, Justin Manjourides, Ki-Do Eum, and Vivian Pun (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from James Enstrom, UCLA (retired) and Scientific Integrity Institute (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from John Dale Dunn, American Council on Science and Health NYC, and Heartland Institute, Chicago (revised 10-23-19) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Kurt E. Blase, Counsel for the Coarse PM Coalition (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Mikko Paunio, University of Helsinki (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Paul Taylor (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Shana Joyce, Texas Oil and Gas Association (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Ted Hadzi-Antich, Texas Public Policy Foundation (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Union of Concerned Scientists (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten comments from the Independent Particulate Matter Review Panel (PDF)
RosterChartered CASAC Roster (PDF)

Top of Page