Meeting

Form on SAB_MEETING

Chartered Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC) Public Meeting on Particulate Matter

12/12/2018 to 12/13/2018



On this page:


See EPA’s PDF page to learn more about PDF files.

Meeting Agenda


Meeting Agenda

The Chartered CASAC will peer review EPA's Integrated Science Assessment (ISA) for Particulate Matter (External Review Draft & October 2018).

Meeting Materials


Meeting Materials


Disclaimer Although not required to do so, EPA generally posts public comments submitted to the SAB, CASAC or Council and their subcommittees on the internet to make them easily available to the public. Posting of public comments is not an Agency endorsement of, or agreement with, any information or viewpoints presented in the public comment, nor is it an Agency endorsement of the quality or correctness of such information and viewpoints. In addition, mention of any trade names or commercial products in posted meeting material does not constitute a recommendation by EPA or the SAB for use.

CategoryMeeting Material
Agency Briefing MaterialEPA Presentation - Review of the Integrated Science Assessment for Particulate Matter (External Review Draft) (PDF)
Agency Follow-upDr. John Vandenberg (EPA) Response to Dr. Tony Cox's 12-17-18 Follow-up Questions (PDF)
Agency-provided Background MaterialPreamble to the Integrated Science Assessments (November 2015) (PDF)
Committee Members' Comments12-10-18 Preliminary Comments from Members of the CASAC on the PM ISA (PDF)
Committee Members' Comments12-12-18 Updated Preliminary Comments from Dr. Mark Frampton (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background Material12-14-18 Follow-up Questions to the Health Effects Institute from Dr. Tony Cox (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background Material12-17-18 Follow-up Questions for Dr. John Vandenberg (EPA) from Dr. Tony Cox (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialCASAC Chair Memo to Chartered CASAC (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialCharge Question for Response Bullet Points: Executive Summary and Chapter 1 (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialCharge Questions for Bullet Point Responses (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers - Clarifying Public Comments (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public Speaker12-12-18 Clarifying Public Comment from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Albert Rizzo, American Lung Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Anne E. Smith, NERA Economic Consulting, on behalf of the Utility Air Regulatory Group (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Corwin Zigler, The University of Texas at Austin (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Daniel L. Costa (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Douglas Dockery, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from George Allen (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from George Wolff, Air Improvement Resource, Inc., on behalf of the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Giffe Johnson, National Council for Air and Stream Improvement (NCASI) (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Jack Harkema, Michigan State University (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Jia Coco Liu, Electric Power Research Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from John Bachmann, Vision Air Consulting, LLC, on behalf of the Environmental Protection Network (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from John Balmes, University of California at San Francisco (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Lianne Sheppard, University of Washington (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Sonja Sax, Ramboll, on behalf of the American Wood Council, Aluminum Association, and American Iron and Steel Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Stewart E. Holm, American Forest & Paper Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerOral Statement from Ted Steichen, American Petroleum Institute (API) (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerSlides for Oral Statement from Kurt Blase, Blase Group LLC, on behalf of the Coarse PM Coalition (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff Office02-21-19 Health Effects Institute Response to Dr. Cox's 12-14-18 Follow-up Questions (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff Office02-27-19 Written Comments from H. Christopher Frey, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from 15 Former Members of the CASAC PM Review Panel that was Disbanded on October 11, 2018 (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from 206 scientists and engineers with expertise in air quality, environmental sciences, and public health (Updated 12-10-18) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Andrew Grieshop, North Carolina State University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Anne E. Smith, NERA Economic Consulting, on behalf of the Utility Air Regulatory Group (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Anthony Maciorowski (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Cara Nichole Maesano, Pierre Louis Institute of Epidemiology and Public Health, INSERM, and Sorbonne University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from George T. Wolff and Jon M. Heuss, Air Improvement Resource, Inc., on behalf of the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Gretchen Goldman, Union of Concerned Scientists (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from H. Kenneth Fisher (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from John Bachmann, Vision Air Consulting, LLC, on behalf of the Environmental Protection Network (updated 12-09-18) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Jonathan Samet, Colorado School of Public Health (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Kevin Cromar, New York University School of Medicine (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Paul Ruscher, Lane Community College (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from Roger McClellan (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Coarse PM Coalition-12-05-18 (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Coarse PM Coalition-12-11-18 (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Electric Power Research Institute (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Health Effects Institute (HEI) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Michael J. Fox Foundation (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the National Council for Air and Stream Improvement (NCASI) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from the Northeast States for Coordinated Air Use Management (NESCAUM) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeWritten Comments from William S. Beckett, Harvard Medical School (PDF)
RosterChartered CASAC Roster (PDF)

Top of Page