Meeting

Form on SAB_MEETING

Public Meeting of the Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC) Particulate Matter (PM) Panel

11/17/2021 to 12/02/2021



On this page:


See EPA’s PDF page to learn more about PDF files.

Meeting Agenda


Meeting Agenda

To peer review EPA’s Draft Supplement to the 2019 Integrated Science Assessment (ISA) for PM and the Draft PM Policy Assessment (PA).

Meeting Materials


Meeting Materials


Disclaimer Although not required to do so, EPA generally posts public comments submitted to the SAB, CASAC or Council and their subcommittees on the internet to make them easily available to the public. Posting of public comments is not an Agency endorsement of, or agreement with, any information or viewpoints presented in the public comment, nor is it an Agency endorsement of the quality or correctness of such information and viewpoints. In addition, mention of any trade names or commercial products in posted meeting material does not constitute a recommendation by EPA or the SAB for use.

CategoryMeeting Material
Agency-provided Background MaterialPreamble to the Integrated Science Assessments - November 2015 (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsISA Supplement - 11-15-21 - Preliminary CASAC PM Panel Member Comments (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsISA Supplement - 11-18-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Jane Clougherty (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsISA Supplement - 11-18-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Terry Gordon (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 11-15-21 - Preliminary CASAC PM Panel Member Comments (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 11-17-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Michelle Bell (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 11-29-21 - Preliminary Comments from Mr. George Allen (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 11-30-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Stephanie Lovinsky-Desir (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 12-01-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. James Boylan (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 12-02-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Jane Clougherty (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 12-02-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Michael Kleinman (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 12-02-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. Terry Gordon (PDF)
Committee Members' CommentsPA - 12-06-21 - Preliminary Comments from Dr. John Balmes (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialLinks to EPA’s 2019 Particulate Matter Integrated Science Assessment and 2020 Particulate Matter Policy Assessment (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialPrevious CASAC Advice on Particulate Matter (PDF)
Committee-Developed or Provided Background MaterialSlides of Dr. Bell's Summary of Key Points on Health Effects Sections (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers for 11/17/21 (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers for 11/19/21 (PDF)
List of public speakersList of Registered Public Speakers for 12/2/21 (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Dan Costa (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from David Hill, American Lung Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from James Enstrom, UCLA and Scientific Integrity Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Nicholas Nassikas, American Thoracic Society (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Omobola Mudasiru, American Petroleum Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Richard L. Smith, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Steve Milloy, Junkscience.com (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerISA Supplement - 11-19-21 - Clarifying Comments from Ned Mulcahy, Group Against Smog and Pollution (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPA - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Albert Rizzo, American Lung Association (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPA - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Brent Bennett, Texas Public Policy Foundation (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPA - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from James Enstrom, UCLA and Scientific Integrity Institute (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPA - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from John Bachmann, Environmental Protection Network (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPA - 11-17-21 - Oral Statement from Vijay Limaye, Natural Resources Defense Council (PDF)
Presentation by Registered Public SpeakerPA - 12-2-21 - Oral Statement from John Graham, Clean Air Task Force (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from Richard L. Smith, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from Warren Kindzierski (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from the American Lung Association (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from the Environmental Protection Network (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from the Health Effects Institute (HEI) (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement Comments from the North American Chapter of the International Society for Environmental Epidemiology (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficeISA Supplement and PA Comments from Harvey Risch, Yale University (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePA Comments from Julie Goodman, Gradient (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePA Comments from Matthew Mehalik, Breathe Project (PDF)
Public comment submitted to the SAB Staff OfficePA Comments from Myron Arnowitt, Clean Water Action (PDF)
RosterCASAC PM Panel Roster (PDF)

Top of Page